MailScale

Services · Deliverability Repair

Deliverability repair: "delivered" is not the same as "inboxed"

The most expensive email problem is the invisible one. A membership app came to us showing 99% delivered in their ESP while GlockApps seed tests showed only 78% of mail reaching the Gmail inbox. The rest sat in spam, unopened by definition. Deliverability repair finds that gap, closes it, and installs the monitoring that keeps it closed.

What broke, and how do we find it?

Deliverability failures cluster around four causes: missing or misaligned authentication, complaint rates over Gmail's thresholds, sustained sends to unengaged profiles, and list-quality problems like purchased addresses or spam traps. Week one is diagnosis: DNS records, Google Postmaster Tools reputation history, complaint trends, and a GlockApps seed baseline across Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo.

What are the fixes?

What does recovery look like in numbers?

The membership app's seven-week arc: 29% of profiles suppressed in weeks two through four, complaint rate down from 0.36% to 0.05%, Gmail placement from 78% to 98%, and the cancel-save flow's click rate up from 3.4% to 6.1% once it was reaching inboxes again. The complete timeline is in the fitness app write-up.

After recovery, monitoring stays on: monthly GlockApps seeds, Postmaster reputation checks, and complaint-rate alerts at 0.1%, well under Google's 0.3% enforcement line. Deliverability is a maintenance discipline, and it is included in every Growth Retainer.

Deliverability questions

How do I know if our emails are going to spam?

Your ESP dashboard cannot tell you. "Delivered" only means a mailbox provider accepted the message; spam-folder placement still counts as delivered. We run GlockApps seed-list tests across Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo to measure real inbox placement, and check your Gmail reputation in Google Postmaster Tools.

What are the Gmail and Yahoo bulk sender requirements?

Since February 2024, senders over 5,000 messages a day to Gmail must authenticate with SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, offer RFC 8058 one-click unsubscribe, and keep spam complaints under 0.3%, with 0.1% as the recommended ceiling. Yahoo enforces matching rules. Miss them and mail gets filtered or rejected outright.

How long does deliverability repair take?

Plan on 4 to 8 weeks. Authentication fixes land in days, but mailbox providers move reputation slowly and only respond to sustained engagement signals. The fitness app in our proof write-up went from 78% to 98% Gmail inbox placement over 7 weeks, with the suppression phase doing most of the early work.

Will we have to shrink our list?

Almost certainly, and it is the point. Sending to silent profiles teaches Gmail your mail is unwanted. The fitness app suppressed 29% of its 78k profiles under a sunset policy; complaints fell from 0.36% to 0.05% and placement recovered. A smaller list that lands beats a big one that does not.

Get a real inbox placement number

One GlockApps baseline test tells you more than a quarter of ESP dashboards. Book a call and we'll set one up against your domain.